This one is a bit lewd. I think this counts as not covered up properly as a significant part of her chest is out of her top, the cleavage is quite deep. Something on this level would be ok for the adult characters but I like to keep it cleaner for the kids.
To compare it with the Sakurako pic that got some heat some days ago, it was a similar picture in nature but the whole of Sakurako’s chest was contained in her top contrasting it to this post. In that case I rejected that there was anything wrong with the pose (this pose is fine as well).
- cited post: https://lemmy.world/post/30407660
It’s hard to put into words exactly what will be allowed and how terms as “decently covered up in sensitive areas” are interpreted. I will take a case law like approach, setting precedents as we go. This is one such precedent as was the Sakurako case some days ago. I updated the posting guidelines with these cases so posters can have more insight before posting (https://lemmy.world/post/7741886).
Because
- this is a light breakage of the rules (as I envisioned them)
- no reasonably similar precedent was set in the past
- it was not controversial in the community (see votes)
this post will stay up. However now the precedent has been set against cleavage of underage characters going into the future.
Anyone is welcome to argue my positions as always. Thank you.
I agree with you. She looks kinda slightly older than in the anime or manga, if I posted that picture somewhere in c/SleepyAnime or !anime_art@ani.social, most (who didn’t watch yryr) would assume she is 17-19 y.o., but it is not so in Yuru Yuri spicific community, so I was hoping to get away with it. In the mean time, I don’t want this community to turn into something bad and I trust your opinion.
Now there are links to all risky posts in the header, it’s both cool and a bit questionable, cz now everyone is able to view sensetive? content immediately. In my opinion it’s better leave the filtering of inappropriate content at the discretion of the mod, maybe r/k_on’s content is pretty wholesome (comparing to maybe r/LuckyStar and r/BocchiTheRock), because of that. Keeping a moderation log about why this or that was banned (warned) it’s ok, but still… maybe replace links with post ids or usernames or discuss it only in comments or something else…
Since we’ve brought this up: some questions.
no deep cleavage is allowed
that means large breasts are ok? In case of Himawari it’s hard to say what really large means, so this pic from pixiv is undesirable, isn’t it?
In general there is no Bakkin Buckingham for kisses, if rules are followed?
As a rule of thumb, I prefer not to post picutres that are tagged as
rating:sensetiveon donmai.You need to be able to view the posts in order for them to function as a guideline. They are not that bad because I would remove them otherwise. I don’t think most people will go into the guidelines and scroll way down anyway, unless they are looking to post something.
Cleavage is about exposing parts of the breasts by lack of clothing in the middle, it is not about the actual size of the breasts. So Himawari being big is not a problem. You show a picture of Himako and Sakurako in their seifuku, which doesn’t have cleavage or exposes them in any other ways to it’s ok.
Kissing is no problem either, romantic material is allowed.
