Every one you mentioned is great! I really enjoy all of the villainess isekai, and Trapped in a Dating Sim is really a hilarious variation that came early in the dating sim sub genre. I love it when the main character is a villain.

Ascendance of a Bookworm is a favorite of my wife and I. We’ve rewatched it a few times, as it has a cozy feel to it sometimes. I really hope they continue the story but it is at a decent enough stopping point if doesn’t get any more seasons.

“The Saint’s Magic Power is Omnipotent” was pretty good. I agree with lots of the others people already listed, but this one makes her age a relevant plot issue which basically sets the tone. It’s a romance anime with light combat and a good amount of world building. 2 seasons.

My wife and I really enjoyed this one. She’ll be happy to hear she gets more.

Because of how disposable every character is in this show, they have so many it’s hard for me to keep up.

I am enjoying it, but its hard to remember names. I hope this isn’t one of hi-dive shows that just never gets a dub, so I can rewatch and gleam some more character from a 2nd viewing.

That is the natural path of reincarnation, isn’t it? LOL