poop

  • 1 Post
  • 48 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle
  • I really enjoyed this one too, I think it’s an essential watch for Haruhi fans, or more specifically, Nagato Yuki fans, but not really for anyone else.

    yes it does finish a bit weakly and on a mild cliffhanger because, as is unfortunately common, it’s only a partial adaptation roughly covering the events from 5 volumes of a 10 volume series. so there’s a fair bit more to read if you want to continue it but they have cut out a lot of extra fluff and a bit of bloat from the manga. they did a fairly good job streamlining the manga into a 16 episode series. a full 2-cour would have been too long and drawn out, a standard 12eps would have been too short to cover both the light hearted SOL rom-com fluff and the more serious arc they adapted very well that crosses it into the main Haruhi universe.


  • I think the main complaints from most people are that the pacing is a bit hard to watch. I know the original manga was fast paced and a little goofy, I read quite a bit of it back when I got super into gits years ago, a far cry from the slow and cerebral movie adaptations, but I think I had hoped this more direct and true adaptation would find the middle ground.

    I’m enjoying it, but it’s hard to watch, i’m nearly 40 and have always preferred “slower” media, and some shows can be either fast or slow paced and an episode is over in what feels like 5 minutes, regardless of how much or how little has actually happened, but this one is often a bit of a slog, never quite getting me into that flow state in a lot of episodes.

    I doubt it’s the last GITS adaptation we get though, I love when we get different interpretations of a source material whether every one is better than the last is irrelevant.


  • I’m quite enjoying it, since I like the manga quite a bit, and I think it looks great, visually, but the pacing is a bit difficult.

    It’s not Anime of the year material by any means. each episode feels fast but also slow if you know what I mean, some shows can have nothing happen at all yet a 24 minute episode is over in the blink of an eye, and others can advance a story a dozen chapters and feel like a complete slog to get through the episode. this adaptation is a bit of a slog to watch, despite being as busy and fast paced as it is.

    I know people always ask for more direct adaptations of manga to screen, but sometimes you do have to change things, skip things, add parts, extend scenes, slow things down, rearrange plotline timing, etc. to make it work on screen. this adaptation needed some more of that.





  • Beyond the usual Dragon Ball and Pokemon things, along with catching random episodes of Sailor Moon, Hamtaro, Cardcaptor Sakura etc on morning TV before school, It was Evangelion, Bebop and couple of years later FLCL on late night TV. I also remember seeing a few random episodes of Escaflowne as well in the 90’s.

    I later completely watched and got very into Eva and Cowboy Bepop, but i still didn’t really think of it as Anime for some reason.

    so beyond those the first “modern” anime that I watched and actually got into the media properly with was Haruhi, then the first thing I watched in Japanese instead of English was Hibike! Euphonium.

    so that’s where I stopped watching dubs for shows other than the classic dub series where most people also listen dubbed.












  • There’s something about slice of life as a genre in general.

    I guess its a sort of melancholy rose-tinted look at something a lot of people either missed out on entirely during our school years, or that we once had but lost as we all grew up and grew apart.

    Hibike! Euphonium (the whole series, movies and the perfect masterpiece Liz and the Blue Bird) hits that for me as well, I was never a band kid, but I feel like it’s 100% relatable regardless. Do it Yourself was the same, that was a great little show.