I just want to complain. I am disappointed. Sigh. That’s it.

  • cobysev@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    12 hours ago

    I’m on the opposite end of the spectrum. As someone who’s been a huge fan of Ghost in the Shell for literal decades, I’m excited to see a new series that’s not only a faithful adaptation of the original manga, but the first video media to replicate the original art style and preserve personalities from the manga. I’m tired of seeing a Major who’s either borderline robot or a strict leader/boss type. Her character has depth and emotions in the manga! She could be hot-headed too!

    Other variations of the media have been interesting in their own isolated universes, but nothing has come close to recreating the original work.

    I’m actually binging the whole 2026 series right now. I haven’t seen the final episode yet, but my wife was getting lost on the overall plot, having only watched it one episode per week as it’s releasing. So we’re re-watching everything, including the final episode, tonight. I’m excited for the conclusion!

    I’m also curious if they’ll make a season 2 that follows volume 2 of the manga. The original work was written as a singular isolated volume, but its popularity led Shirow Masamune to write a second volume after the fact. Plus a volume 1.5 to fill in some gaps between the two volumes.

    Regardless, this sole season should tell a complete story without any additional episodes or seasons. That is, if it stays loyal to the manga. And I’m fine with that.


    EDIT: I just finished the show. Yup, it was loyal to the manga, right to the end. The Puppet Master bit near the end felt a bit sudden and rushed. They had a few episodes where they could’ve done a better job building it up instead of info-dumping at the very end of the final episode. But otherwise, I highly approve. I’m glad to see a manga-accurate retelling for once.

    The 1995 Ghost in the Shell movie was the closest thing to retelling the original manga we’ve had before, and if you’ve seen it, you’ll probably recognize similar scenes and stories in this 2026 show.

    But the movie changed the look and personality/behavior of everyone. Not to mention, it had to condense an entire volume of manga into an 80-minute film, so it solely focused on the Puppet Master story, with a few philosophical discussions mixed in. Gotta touch on the philosophy of what the “ghost” in the “shell” is all about, right?

    The 2017 Ghost in the Shell was just a live-action retelling of the 1995 movie, with a slightly altered plot. But it flopped because they cast ScarJo to play a typically Japanese main character. Even if they provided an in-universe explanation for why the Major looked American. It didn’t sit well with audiences.

    Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex is its own thing, set in a similar world and maybe touching on a couple familiar stories from the manga, but mostly creating its own plot to explore. It’s excellent on its own, but it has almost nothing to do with the original manga.

    Same with Ghost in the Shell: Arise. It was a prequel series, showing the Major’s early days, but it’s not connected to the source material at all. If I recall, I don’t think it’s even canon with Stand Alone Complex either.

    Overall, I’m very pleased with this 2026 version and it will be the version I recommend to anyone who wants to get into Ghost in the Shell without reading the original source manga.